Small Shipping Delay: View Details
Track My Order My Profile Help
Authorized NZ Stockist
Buy Makeup NZ Afterpay Laybuy Zip
Beauty Bliss Rewards Points
FILTERS
COLOUR
BROWSE ALL
Accessories & Tools (142)
BB Value Picks (42)
Body (351)
Fragrance (86)
Hair (1911)
Halloween (173)
Holiday 2024 (5)
Kids & Baby (106)
Makeup (2708)
Makeup Brushes (183)
Makeup Remover & Wipes (44)
Men (115)
Nails (164)
Pets (5)
Sets & Gifts (120)
SFX Makeup (229)
Skincare (665)
Valentine's Day (23)
Wellness (101)
Makeup Eye Makeup Brows Pencils

Shop Pencils

Sort by featured Sort by newness Sort by average rating Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low
Eyebrow pencils help to fill and define your brows. Available in thicker, softer formulas for bold looks - through to super fine-tipped formulas that help create more definition and natural looks with the appearance of individual hair strokes.
Sort by featured Sort by newness Sort by average rating Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low
Filter products +
NEW
Lash Icons Limited Edition Collection Lash Icons Limited Edition Collection
RevitaLash Lash Icons Limited Edition Collection
1 review
$209.00
  In stock
NEW
Brow Icons Limited Edition Collection Brow Icons Limited Edition Collection
RevitaLash Brow Icons Limited Edition Collection
$169.00
  In stock
Dual Brow Perfect Dual Brow Perfect
Eye of Horus Dual Brow Perfect
OFFER
12 reviews
$42.00
  In stock
Great Brows Now, Pay Later
Brow Define Brow Define
Eye of Horus Brow Define
OFFER
10 reviews
$39.00
  In stock
Hi-Def Brow Pencil Hi-Def Brow Pencil
RevitaLash Hi-Def Brow Pencil
$49.90
  In stock
Shady Slim Brow Pencil Shady Slim Brow Pencil
LA Girl Shady Slim Brow Pencil
34 reviews
$12.95
  In stock
Contour Pencil Contour Pencil
Kryolan Contour Pencil
8 reviews
$20.00
  In stock
Eyebrow Pencil Eyebrow Pencil
Australis Eyebrow Pencil
13 reviews
$12.00
  In stock
Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil
Wet n Wild Brow-Sessive Brow Pencil
2 reviews
$7.95
  In stock
Relove Blade Brow Pencil Relove Blade Brow Pencil
Makeup Revolution Relove Blade Brow Pencil
OFFER
$11.95
  In stock
Relove Power Brow Pencil - Granite Relove Power Brow Pencil - Granite
Makeup Revolution Relove Power Brow Pencil - Granite
OFFER
$6.00
  In stock
Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil
LA Girl Featherlite Brow Shaping Powder Pencil
2 reviews
$19.95
  In stock
Instant Brows Pencil Instant Brows Pencil
MCoBeauty Instant Brows Pencil
1 review
$18.95
  In stock
SAVE $4.20 Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Soft Black Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Soft Black
Revlon Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Soft Black
$28.00 $23.80
  In stock
Black/Brown Twin Pencil Black/Brown Twin Pencil
Kryolan Black/Brown Twin Pencil
$21.00
  In stock
ColorStay Brow Creator™ ColorStay Brow Creator™
Revlon ColorStay Brow Creator™
$32.00 $27.20
  In stock
Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil
MCoBeauty Everyday Perfect Brow Pencil
$18.95
  In stock
SAVE $4.20 Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Auburn Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Auburn
Revlon Colorstay™ Brow Pencil - Auburn
$28.00 $23.80
  In stock

Recent reviews in Pencils

Lash Icons Limited Edition Collection
RevitaLash
Lash Icons Limited Edition Collection
$209.00
Bargain pack!

I regularly buy the mascara and eyelash serum. This limited edition is a steal! Makes lashes long and the mascara is my hands down fav. I've used other brands and this is the only one that gives me results.

- dc
Dual Brow Perfect - Husk (Ash Blonde)
Eye of Horus
Dual Brow Perfect - Husk (Ash Blonde)
$42.00
My absolute favourite

The only eye brow product I use & continue to reorder.

- Gillian
Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Espresso
LA Girl
Shady Slim Brow Pencil - Espresso
$12.95
Good product

Pretty good tbh really natural 👍

- Lena