View our latest offers
Track My Order My Profile Help
Authorized NZ Stockist
Buy Makeup NZ Afterpay Laybuy Zip
Beauty Bliss Rewards Points
AVAILABILITY
FILTERS
COLOUR
BROWSE ALL
Accessories & Tools (143)
BB Value Picks (42)
Body (351)
Fragrance (87)
Hair (1907)
Halloween (174)
Holiday 2024 (4)
Kids & Baby (107)
Makeup (2663)
Makeup Brushes (183)
Makeup Remover & Wipes (43)
Men (115)
Nails (167)
Pets (5)
Sets & Gifts (119)
SFX Makeup (230)
Skincare (661)
Valentine's Day (23)
Wellness (101)
Makeup Eye Makeup Eyeliner Pencil
Goddess Eye Pencil Goddess Eye Pencil
Eye of Horus Goddess Eye Pencil
OFFER
16 reviews
$37.00
  In stock - Ships today
Eye Definer Eye Definer
Dr. Hauschka Eye Definer
OFFER
$34.20
  In stock - Ships today
VALUE BUNDLE
Goddess Eyes Bundle Goddess Eyes Bundle
Eye of Horus Goddess Eyes Bundle
OFFER
$72.00
  In stock - Ships today
Afterpay Makeup Hair and Skin NZ
Defining Liner Eyeliner Defining Liner Eyeliner
RevitaLash Defining Liner Eyeliner
$49.00
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $4.80 Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - Cool as Ice Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - Cool as Ice
Revlon Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - Cool as Ice
$32.00 $27.20
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $4.80 Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - She's on Fire Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - She's on Fire
Revlon Colorstay Line Creator™ Double Ended Liner - She's on Fire
$32.00 $27.20
  In stock - Ships today
Ultimate Auto Eyeliner Ultimate Auto Eyeliner
LA Girl Ultimate Auto Eyeliner
25 reviews
$12.95
  In stock - Ships today
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil
Wet n Wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil
39 reviews
$2.95
  In stock - Ships today
*69 Gel Eyeliner *69 Gel Eyeliner
af94 *69 Gel Eyeliner
4 reviews
$20.00 $17.00
  In stock - Ships today
Contour Pencil Contour Pencil
Kryolan Contour Pencil
8 reviews
$20.00
  In stock - Ships today
Eyeliner Pencils Eyeliner Pencils
Australis Eyeliner Pencils
21 reviews
$12.00
  In stock - Ships today
Stayput Liner Stayput Liner
Australis Stayput Liner
4 reviews
$14.00
  In stock - Ships today
Kajal Pencil Kajal Pencil
Kryolan Kajal Pencil
1 review
$18.00
  In stock - Ships today
ColorStay™ Eyeliner ColorStay™ Eyeliner
Revlon ColorStay™ Eyeliner
$28.00 $23.80
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $2.25 Kohl Eyeliner - Brown Kohl Eyeliner - Brown
Makeup Revolution Kohl Eyeliner - Brown
OFFER
2 reviews
$9.00 $6.75
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $2.25 Kohl Eyeliner - White Kohl Eyeliner - White
Makeup Revolution Kohl Eyeliner - White
OFFER
2 reviews
$9.00 $6.75
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $2.25 Kohl Eyeliner - Black Kohl Eyeliner - Black
Makeup Revolution Kohl Eyeliner - Black
OFFER
4 reviews
$9.00 $6.75
  In stock - Ships today
Waterproof Eye Define Crayon Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof Eye Define Crayon Pencil Eyeliner
MCoBeauty Waterproof Eye Define Crayon Pencil Eyeliner
3 reviews
$13.95
  In stock - Ships today
Black/Brown Twin Pencil Black/Brown Twin Pencil
Kryolan Black/Brown Twin Pencil
$21.00
  In stock - Ships today
Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black
Revolution Pro Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black
1 review
$13.95
  In stock - Ships today
Hypereasy No Slip Eyeliner Pencil Hypereasy No Slip Eyeliner Pencil
Maybelline Hypereasy No Slip Eyeliner Pencil
1 review
$23.95
  In stock - Ships today
Faceliner Pencil Faceliner Pencil
Kryolan Faceliner Pencil
$32.50
  In stock - Ships today
SAVE $4.20 So Fierce!™ Vinyl Eyeliner - Force of Steel So Fierce!™ Vinyl Eyeliner - Force of Steel
Revlon So Fierce!™ Vinyl Eyeliner - Force of Steel
$28.00 $23.80
  In stock - Ships today
Master Liner Creamy Pencil Master Liner Creamy Pencil
Maybelline Master Liner Creamy Pencil
2 reviews
$20.95
  In stock - Ships today
Shimmer Crayons
Ben Nye Shimmer Crayons
$33.00
  In stock with supplier
SAVE $4.20 ColorStay Micro™ Hyper Precision Gel Eyeliner - Beige ColorStay Micro™ Hyper Precision Gel Eyeliner - Beige
Revlon ColorStay Micro™ Hyper Precision Gel Eyeliner - Beige
$28.00 $23.80
  In stock - Ships today

Recent reviews in Pencil

Stayput Liner - Midnight
Australis
Stayput Liner - Midnight
$14.00
Loveee

Favourite eyeliner ever. Only one I use anymore! :)

- Mya
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil - Baby's Got Black
Wet n Wild
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil - Baby's Got Black
$2.95
Not bad

Needs topping up quite often so I do get watery eyes so not quite water proof

- Kyla
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil - You're Always White!
Wet n Wild
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil - You're Always White!
$2.95
really good for the price!!

great for the waterline, but does need reapplication after a few hours

- shay