View our latest offers
Track My Order My Profile Beauty Blog Help
AVAILABILITY
BROWSE ALL
Accessories & Tools (172)
BB Value Picks (60)
Body (314)
Father's Day (29)
Fragrance (176)
Body Mist (11)
Candles (42)
Diffusers (74)
Perfume & Cologne (55)
Men (3)
Women (50)
Room Spray (4)
Hair (2556)
Halloween (264)
Holiday 2025 (97)
Kids & Baby (118)
Makeup (3018)
Makeup Brushes (151)
Makeup Remover & Wipes (36)
Men (180)
Nails (242)
Pets (7)
Professional Makeup Artist Tools (59)
Refills (35)
Sets & Gifts (158)
SFX Makeup (334)
Skincare (727)
Wellness (133)
Makeup Eye Makeup Eyeliner Pencil
Goddess Eye Pencil Goddess Eye Pencil
Eye of Horus Goddess Eye Pencil
19 reviews
$43.00
OFFER: Free lipstick when you spend $49 with Eye of Horus*
  In stock - Ships today
Eye Definer Eye Definer
Dr. Hauschka Eye Definer
$35.60
OFFER: Free gift when you spend $80 on Dr Hauschka*
  In stock - Ships today
Defining Liner Eyeliner Defining Liner Eyeliner
RevitaLash Defining Liner Eyeliner
$49.00
  In stock - Ships today
Afterpay Makeup Hair and Skin NZ
Long-Lasting Eye Pencil Long-Lasting Eye Pencil
essence Long-Lasting Eye Pencil
7 reviews
$4.49
  In stock - Ships today
Ultimate Auto Eyeliner Ultimate Auto Eyeliner
LA Girl Ultimate Auto Eyeliner
29 reviews
$14.95
  In stock - Ships today
Kajal Pencil Kajal Pencil
essence Kajal Pencil
4 reviews
$2.99
  In stock - Ships today
Contour Pencil Contour Pencil
Kryolan Contour Pencil
10 reviews
$20.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $99 on Kryolan*
  In stock - Ships today
Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil
Wet n Wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil
43 reviews
$4.95
OFFER: Free gift when you spend $39 on Wet n Wild*
  In stock - Ships today
Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer
$15.50 $12.40
ON SALE
  In stock - Ships today
Eyeliner Pencils Eyeliner Pencils
Australis Eyeliner Pencils
23 reviews
$12.00
  In stock - Ships today
Kohl Eyeliner - Black Kohl Eyeliner - Black
Makeup Revolution Kohl Eyeliner - Black
4 reviews
$8.95
OFFER: Free matte lipstick when you spend $19 on Makeup Revolution*
  In stock - Ships today
Faceliner Pencil Faceliner Pencil
Kryolan Faceliner Pencil
$34.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $99 on Kryolan*
  In stock - Ships today
Stayput Liner Stayput Liner
Australis Stayput Liner
4 reviews
$14.00
  In stock - Ships today
Black Gel Eyeliner Black Gel Eyeliner
Kryolan Black Gel Eyeliner
$32.90
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $99 on Kryolan*
  In stock - Ships today
Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black
Makeup Revolution Visionary Gel Eyeliner Pencil - Black
2 reviews
$13.95
OFFER: Free matte lipstick when you spend $19 on Makeup Revolution*
  In stock - Ships today
Kajal Pencil Kajal Pencil
Kryolan Kajal Pencil
1 review
$23.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $99 on Kryolan*
  In stock with supplier
Kohl Eyeliner - White Kohl Eyeliner - White
Makeup Revolution Kohl Eyeliner - White
2 reviews
$8.95
OFFER: Free matte lipstick when you spend $19 on Makeup Revolution*
  In stock - Ships today
NEW
Chameleon Chrome Eyeliner Chameleon Chrome Eyeliner
Wet n Wild Chameleon Chrome Eyeliner
$12.95
OFFER: Free gift when you spend $39 on Wet n Wild*
  In stock - Ships today
MagiColour Pencil MagiColour Pencil
Ben Nye MagiColour Pencil
$21.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $89 on Ben Nye*
  In stock with supplier
Lasting Drama Eyeliner Lasting Drama Eyeliner
Maybelline Lasting Drama Eyeliner
$22.50
  In stock - Ships today
Shimmer Crayon Shimmer Crayon
Ben Nye Shimmer Crayon
$33.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $89 on Ben Nye*
  In stock with supplier
Contour Pencil Black + Brown Contour Pencil Black + Brown
Kryolan Contour Pencil Black + Brown
$21.00
OFFER: Free Gift when you spend $99 on Kryolan*
  In stock - Ships today

Recent reviews in Pencil

Contour Pencil - Lake 910

Kryolan

Contour Pencil - Lake 910
Quality eyeliner

This eyeliner is amazing, it has a smooth application and the color is super pigmented. I definitely recommend to all and will be purchasing again :)

- Renee
Goddess Eye Pencil - Black

Eye of Horus

Goddess Eye Pencil - Black
My absolute favourite eyeliner.

I have been in the biz and on social media for quite a while. I have never come across an eyeliner pencil that works this well for me. One stroke and you’re done. If this one’s too pricy. Revolution streamliner is my other favourite for half the price.

- Kacey
Long-Lasting Eye Pencil - 12 I Have A Green

essence

Long-Lasting Eye Pencil - 12 I Have A Green
Rich colour

Great product for the money. Colour is super!

- Caroline