Good but not the best
I have a very high standard for giving cleansing balms 5 stars. This is a good one and takes off light makeup however I've tried with waterproof and it doesn't take it off completely, I have to really get in there and work at it to get it off or use another eye makeup remover after. It does take off most makeup though and has no scent. I loooooove the packaging design too, obsessed.
- Zach